GE3LS Digest - November 16, 2009
The GE3LS Digest
A compendium of news and research from around the country and around the world
Date: November 16, 2009
========================================================================
NEWS
========================================================================
CANADA
Two research teams funded through the Innovative Partnership Program
between Canada and California to advance Cancer Stem Cell Research –
October 28th, 2009
http://genomecanada.ca/en/about/news.aspx?i=338
The
Cancer Stem Cell Consortium (CSCC) is pleased to announce that two
multi-disciplinary research teams co-led by Canadian and Californian
scientists have been awarded funding through a Collaborative
Partnership Program with The California Institute for Regenerative
Medicine (CIRM). The program supports research that will result in a
cancer stem cell based therapy with the specific aim of improving
cancer treatment.
Electronic Health Information and Privacy Conference, November 19, 2009, Ottawa, ON
http://www.ehip.ca/
The
theme for the 2009 conference is the collection and use/disclosure of
genetic information. We will address issues concerning the consent and
security mechanisms around the construction of biobanks, including
linking to other data sources. The focus will be on policy as well as
technical issues and solutions. The conference will also cover a number
of very relevant contemporary privacy issues: privacy considerations in
the context of syndromic surveillance (for example, when trying to
detect influenza like illnesses from various hospital and practice
sources), and the expected significant changes to the US Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and HIPAA
enforcement.
Doctoral Thesis Fellowships and Postdoctoral Fellowships: Call For Applications
http://valgen.ca/
A group of Canadian scholars has created
Value Addition Through Genomics and GE³LS (VALGEN), a Genome Canada project managed by Genome Prairie. This project responds to the deep governance challenges and opportunities of applied genomics for bioproducts and crops through research and knowledge mobilization on the core issues of intellectual property management, regulation and governance and democratic engagement.
Up to six doctoral thesis fellowships and three postdoctoral fellowships will be awarded in the three major research areas of VALGEN:
(1) intellectual property management,
(2) regulation and governance, and
(3) democratic engagement.
Fellowships will be located in one or more of the following institutions: University of Saskatchewan, University of Ottawa, University of British Columbia, University of Regina, McGill University, University of Calgary, Laval University, the University of Western Ontario, or other universities in the VALGEN network.
For More Information and to Apply:
An application consisting of a detailed cover letter and C.V. must be submitted by
December 1, 2009.
Submit applications to:
Kari Doerksen, University of Saskatchewan, Johnson-Shoyama Graduate School of Public Policy, 101 Diefenbaker Place, Saskatoon, SK, S7N 5B8 or to
kdoerksen@genomeprairie.ca.
For more information please consult
www.genomecanada.ca and
www.valgen.ca
INTERNATIONAL
Breakthroughs in genetics leave families facing agonising choices – October 31, 2009
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/6475298/Breakthroughs-in-genetics-leave-families-facing-agonising-choices.html
Medical
advances mean those at high risk of passing on some diseases can have
their embryos screened, to prevent the inheritance of some deadly
genes. But doing so has meant receiving shattering information about
whether they carry the same gene, which means their own life is
destined to be cut short. Now, a new test case could result in people
being shielded from such news – but experts say it will open the door
to even more complex ethical dilemmas. Regulators are considering
whether those with a family history of rare genetic diseases should be
given permission to have their embryos screened, and healthy specimens
selected for implantation, while being protected from findings which
would reveal their own fate. The Human Fertilisation and Embryology
Authority (HFEA) is considering a hospital's application to carry out
such screening for patients with a family history of the cruel
degenerative condition Huntington's disease, which has a 50 per cent
chance of being passed from parent to child.
Green Light for Gene Patent Lawsuit – November 3, 2009
http://www.scienceprogress.org/2009/11/green-light-for-gene-patent-lawsuit/
A
U.S. District Court judge ruled Monday that a gene patent lawsuit filed
against the Patent and Trademark Office
could move forward. At issue
are patents exclusively licensed by Myriad Genetics for the BRCA1 and
BRCA2 genes. Mutations of the genes are strongly linked to
significant
risks of breast cancer. The suit, lead by the Association for Molecular
Pathology and including plaintiffs such as the American Civil Liberties
Union, is the
first of its kind, claiming that the patents violate free
speech by inhibiting research. Myriad, along with the USPTO and the
University of Utah Research Foundation, requested that the suit be
dismissed, but the court denied the motion.
For Sale: Human Eggs Become a Research Commodity – November 2, 2009
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=shelling-out-for-eggs
Paying
a woman for her eggs to use in stem cell research has been a bioethical
no-no for years. But this past June, New York State decided to allow
just that, becoming the first state to permit public money to be used
in this way. The decision, which allows payment of up to $10,000, will
likely jump-start donations—and thereby research. Many bioethicists,
however, worry that the financial incentive could exploit women and
compromise their health. Ethical issues surround egg donation because
the process is not without risk. It requires a series of hormonal
stimulation injections as well as an invasive procedure to retrieve the
eggs. The long-term health effects and risks of complication are not
well known. A woman who provides eggs for research is “assuming unknown
risk for unknown benefits,” says Debra Mathews, a pediatrician at Johns
Hopkins University. The lingering unknowns prompted the National
Academy of Science to issue in 2005 nonbinding guidelines to prohibit
payment (but allow direct reimbursement for expenses), as a means to
protect underprivileged women in particular.
Genomics: No Longer A Failure – November 2, 2009
http://www.forbes.com/2009/11/02/human-genome-sciences-vertex-business-healthcare-genomics.html
Shares
of Human Genome Sciences and Vertex Pharmaceuticals, tiny drug
developers that first gained during the hype fest that followed the
mapping of the human genetic code a decade ago, are soaring Monday
morning after positive clinical trial results. Human Genome, of
Rockville, Md., rose 39% to $26 in early trading after releasing
positive results from a second study of its drug Benlysta, a treatment
for lupus, an immune disease. The company and Wall Street analysts who
follow it say the result should be enough to secure marketing approval
from the
U.S. Food and Drug Administration. The company hopes to get an
expedited regulatory review that could lead to approval by late next
year. It would be the first really new lupus drug in decades.
It’s my genome: should researchers be obliged to return genetic data to research participants? - November
3, 2009
http://www.genomicslawreport.com/index.php/2009/11/03/its-my-genome-should-researchers-be-obliged-to-return-genetic-data-to-research-participants/
Alice
signed up as a “healthy control” for a research project into the
genetics of type 2 diabetes. During the project, researchers identified
a variation in Alice’s
BRCA1 gene that is known to be associated with a
high risk of breast cancer. Alice is unaware that she carries this
variant, and if she was told about it she would be able to take steps
to minimise her risk of cancer. It is clearly in Alice’s best interests
to be given the option to be informed about this discovery – and yet in
most research studies she would have no such opportunity. Instead,
Alice is likely to have signed an informed consent form advising her
that she will not receive any findings from the research study, and
that indeed she has no automatic right to access any of the data
generated from her DNA during the project. As genetic research studies
move into the era of whole-genome sequencing, and as cohorts of
patients and controls grow ever larger, the frequency with which
researchers uncover such medically relevant “incidental findings” will
increase sharply.
Survey of Academic Life Scientists Suggests 10-Year Drop in Industry Funding – November 5, 2009
http://www.genomeweb.com/print/927189?emc=el&m=541951&l=5&v=42c8152690
Direct
industry funding for academic life science research appears to have
decreased in the last decade, according to the results of a 2007 survey
published this week.The survey also found that academic life scientists
with industry support withheld data or delayed publication due to
commercial prospects more frequently than those with no industry
support during that time. The research, which appears in the
November/December issue of
Health Affairs, was supported by a grant
from the National Human Genome Research Institute. It followed similar
surveys conducted in 1995 and 1985 by the same research group at the
Massachusetts General Hospital Institute for Health Policy, allowing
them to examine trends in industry-academia partnerships over the past
20 years. For the most recent study, in late 2006 and 2007 the
researchers mailed surveys to a randomly selected group of life science
faculty members at the 50 US universities receiving the most NIH
support in 2004. The survey asked a range of questions about
respondents' relationships and activities in the preceding three years.
French scientists appear to halt rare brain disease in 2 boys with new gene therapy approach – November 5, 2009
http://healthandfitness.sympatico.ca/News/ContentPosting?newsitemid=052754324&feedname=CP-HEALTH&show=False&number=0&showbyline=True&subtitle=&detect=&abc=abc&date=True
French
scientists mixed gene therapy and bone marrow transplants in two boys
to seemingly halt the fatal brain disease best known from the movie
"Lorenzo's Oil. The surprise ingredient: They disabled the HIV virus so
it couldn't cause AIDS, and then used it to carry in the healthy new
gene. The experiment marks the first time researchers have tried that
long-contemplated step in people - and the first effective gene therapy
against a severe brain disease, said lead researcher Dr. Patrick
Aubourg of the University Paris-Descartes. Although it is a small,
first-step study, it has "exciting implications" for other blood and
immune disorders that had been feared beyond gene therapy's reach, said
Dr. Kenneth Cornetta, president of the American Society of Gene and
Cell Therapy. "This study shows the power of combining gene therapy and
cell therapy," added Cornetta, whose own lab at Indiana University has
long researched how to safely develop gene delivery using lentiviruses,
HIV's family.
Rules on Modified Corn Skirted, Study Says – November 5, 2009
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/06/business/06corn.html?ref=science
As
many as 25 percent of the American farmers growing genetically
engineered corn are no longer complying with federal rules intended to
maintain the resistance of the crops to damage from insects, according
to a report Thursday from an advocacy group. The increase in farmers
skirting the rules, from fewer than 10 percent a few years ago, raises
the risk that insects will develop resistance to the toxins in the corn
that are meant to kill them, the report says. And it raises questions
about whether the
Environmental Protection Agency and the agricultural
biotechnology industry are adequately enforcing the rules. The data
“should be a wake-up call to E.P.A. that the regulatory system is not
working,” Gregory Jaffe, the report’s author, wrote in a letter
Thursday to
Lisa P. Jackson, the administrator of the federal agency.
Mr. Jaffe is the biotechnology project director at the
Center for
Science in the Public Interest, a Washington advocacy group that does
not oppose genetically engineered crops but favors stricter regulation.
Stem Cells May Offer Alternative to Lung Transplants – November 6, 2009
http://health.msn.com/health-topics/respiratory-problems/articlepage.aspx?cp-documentid=100248162
Belgian
scientists who used embryonic stem cells to create lung tissue say this
technique could provide an alternative to lung transplants for patients
with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and cystic fibrosis.
This is the first time it's been shown that embryonic stem cells can be
converted into airway epithelial-like cells without the use of specific
growth factors or embryoid body formation. The researchers achieved
this using an "air-liquid interface" system that mimics the conditions
found in an adult trachea. "Efforts will be made to further improve
this novel culture protocol, trying to increase the number of
differentiated cells or to guide the differentiation into particular
cell types by adding certain growth factors to this system," Lindsey
Van Haute, of the department of embryology and genetics at the Free
University of Brussels, said in a news release.
Whole genome sequencing under $5,000 –November 9, 2009
http://www.phgfoundation.org/news/4917/
Following
numerous tantalising announcements earlier in the year, US company
Complete Genomics Inc. has now published the results of three complete
genomes, which were sequenced for an average cost of $4,400 each using
its third generation sequencing platform [
Drmanac R et al. (2009)
Science doi: 10.1126/science.1181498]. The company is one of the front
runners in the race to achieve the coveted $1,000 genome, and
previously announced that it “
plans to sequence 10,000 human genomes in
2010” (see
previous news). Although the current price-tag excludes the
platform itself and any associated infrastructure, the consumables cost
between $1,726 and $8,800 for these genomes, which were sequenced at a
coverage ranging from 45- to 87-fold per genome respectively.
Use of animals and embryos containing human material – November 10, 2009
http://www.phgfoundation.org/news/4919/
The
UK Academy of Medical Sciences has launched a new study to examine the
use of animals containing human material (such as DNA) in scientific
research. They say that consideration of this area is needed in the
light of rapid scientific advances ‘
to ensure that research into our
understanding of diseases and their treatment can take place in the UK
within a robust ethical and regulatory framework’. The investigation
will consider transgenic animals and animal embryos containing
integrated ‘human-like genetic material’, and chimeric animals and
animal embryos, containing cells of human origin. For example, this
might include mouse models of human diseases such as Down’s Syndrome,
which are widely used for medical and pharmaceutical research; human
tissues or organs being grown in animals as part of transplantation
research; or the controversial hybrid human-animal embryos for stem
cell research.
==============================================================
PAPERS/REPORTS
==============================================================
Reducing uncertainty in regulatory decision-making for transgenic
crops: More ecological research or shrewder environmental risk
assessment?
http://www.landesbioscience.com/journals/gmcrops/article/9776/
Ecological
research and environmental risk assessment are similar in that they
address interesting problems by formulating and testing hypotheses.
They differ in the types of problem that are interesting, the
characteristics of good hypotheses to solve those problems, and the
methods for rigorous testing of hypotheses. It is important to
recognise the differences between environmental risk assessment and
basic ecological research because confusing them can lead to
ineffective risk assessment and missed opportunities to advance
ecological theory. Uncertainty in regulatory decision-making about
transgenic crops may be reduced more effectively by clarifying the
purpose and structure of environmental risk assessments than by further
research on the ecology of the crops.
==============================================================
CONFERENCES/EVENTS
==============================================================
The GEEE! in Genome
October 2, 2009 – January 4, 2010
Vancouver, British Columbia
http://geenome.ca
The 5th Annual Stem Cell Summit
February 16th, 2010
New York City, NY
http://www.stemcellsummit.com/